Monday, April 22, 2013

Design Challenge for Rosenlundeskolen

Today we went to Rosenlundskolen to meet the Principal, who would be the "user" of our solution camp/design challenge for the rest of the week/workshop. Martin, as the Principal of the school, is charged with the task of finding a way to create "school with a purpose." He explained to us that the government has 3 goals for public schoolst to attain by 2020: to have every student in every school learning at their maximum learning potential, create collaborations, and schools that are good at renewal. As he explained, this will be achieved through activating curiosity, active/buddy learning, cross-grade supervision, building bridges from leisure/home to school, and organized knowledge sharing. He must find a path to converge children's maximized learning with their hope and dreams in the next 2-3 years. Are teachers/students/administrators motivated to make this change/shift? As he explained, teachers seem to be very motivated, however there is a challenge of maintaining this motivation among teachers. He will need to design and implement a plan of radical change of the course of 2-3 years, based on Sir Ken Robinson's video on changing educational paradigms. Martin picked out 5 key points and considerations from the video that he has modeled his proposed change after:
  1. Motivation: "Aesthetic experience is when the senses are operating at their peak."
  2. Acknowledging children's differences: Is it most important to organize children by their "date of manufacture" (i.e. age)?
  3. Build a bridge between leisure and school: Students are bored, so in order to keep them engaged, we must make learning meaningful, purposeful, practical, and applicable to real life.
  4. Focus on collaboration: "Great learning happens in groups. Collaboration is the stuff of growth."
  5. Focus on the development of creativity: We all have the capacity for creativity. In order to create new solutions, we need to transfer knowledge from one area to another.
It was a very interesting session - we discussed the challenges that he was faced with. I found many of them to be similar: teachers adapting to increasingly diverse classes and schools; teachers maintaining competence; political limitations; and the task of "shifting educational paradigms," as Ken Robinsons discusses, while being constrained by the current educational systems. Today was focused on thoroughly understanding Martin's perspective on the situation, as he (in addition to the teachers, and students, of course) is who we will be designing the solution for. I found that since many of the students did not have any prior knowledge or understand of the Danish public school system, a lot of the time was used for basic, practical questions so it did not allow us to get as much insight into the deeper issues as I would have hoped. Since we Canadian students had a meeting with our practicum supervisors, as well as students from the UCC to learn about the Danish school system, I had some background knowledge, and was hoping to ask some deeper questions. I think it is very important for students to have background knowledge of a situation, before expecting them to develop any deeper understanding, as in Bloom's Taxonomy model (knowledge comes before comprehension). Nonetheless, we had an opportunity to spend a fair amount of time in the empathy step, which was helpful to gain an understanding of the problem, before we had to define it. As I have mentioned before, I notice many similarities between the current education system in Denmark, the challenges with maximizing student learning, and even the approaches (links between home and school; collaboration; developing creativity, creative thinking and creative problem solving). The most difficult thing for me is that I find the more we analyse the problem and issues, the more complex we realize the problem is, the more obstacles there are, and the more difficult it becomes to design a solution that solves the basis of the problem, as well as all the subsequent ones that pop up once you look deeper. It becomes a little disheartening. But that is why the boot-camp process is good - we look at the problem, ideate a variety of solutions, try them out, get feedback, and revise them. It forces us to be productive, when otherwise (at least I) we might get paralyzed by all the issues we encounter. Back to it tomorrow!

Saturday, April 20, 2013

Design-Based Learning

Joy's prototype of a fox laundry bag gift to
give my friend
During today's session, we learned about designed-based learning through active participation. We went through each steps of the Design-Based Learning process, using a video from the d.school program at Stanford University. This workshop used both a process- and product-oriented approach to learning and creative problem-solving. First, we went through the process in partners, then collaboratively as a group. We spent a lot of a time in the empathy step, where we took turns sharing our most recent gift-giving experience, and how it made us feel. We then made inferences on the reason/needs behind the gift-giving experience, in order to define the problem statement that we needed to design a solution for. We generated at least 5 ideas that we had to represent through pictures, and then chose the best one to create an actual prototype for, checking in and receiving feedback after each step. It was a very fast-paced workshop, however the time-constraints allowed us to work from our intuition instead of deliberating over making decisions, which was quite effective. In the afternoon, we worked in our discussion groups to design a solution to one of the pretask issues from Holland, after watching a quick presentation on it. The issue was inclusion and multiculturalism in schools, which is also a problem in the Canadian school system, with all of the immigrants and refugees that are prevalent through schools. When we worked together as a group, we were able to converge our ideas into one "solution," after we'd followed through the design process.

Prototypes of the design challenge from the morning session
I enjoyed the activity in the morning, as it allowed me to really get to know and empathize with my partner, a neighbour from Canada. I found it very interesting that we both took completely different approaches to problem-solving - mine was more abstract and focusing on what need of her own she is meeting by giving gifts, while she focused on helping me find a thoughtful gift for my friend. After going through the initial empathy step, we moved through the process: define, ideate, prototype, test. This moved very quickly, almost in a lock-step boot-camp style, as this is how "design" tasks are in real life - we have to meet deadlines and can't get stuck in any particular step for too long or nothing will get done! While this approach to problem-solving was very exhausting and trying, it was overall a productive experience. I think it would be very interesting to use the "design-challenge" approach to design in an art or scientific problem-solving class. I would like the students to do a reflective assessment on the process so that I could get feedback and see how they felt about it.


Our group's survival camp map design
 The afternoon posed more of a unique, abstract challenge - designing and creating a "product" for a more theoretical issue. I mean that you cannot just create a single object to solve the complex problem. After the morning's intensive session, we were all quite exhausted, so it was difficult to stay engaged. After the presentation on Holland's issues of social inclusion in education, we jumped right back into the design challenge. Through divergent (each brainstorming and developing ideas) and then convergent thinking (synthesizing them together into a cohesive plan), our group eventually came up with a survival bootcamp, within which we each contributed an idea. We designed a sketch of our bootcamp with each of our ideas and then created a prototype I was really quite impressed with our group's idea and felt that each person had such a valuable contribution, and furthermore, created such a unique and creative prototype! I was very energized and inspired after today's session. Sometimes I do not have the perseverance or motivation to actually create products, but when I do am always very inspired after :) I will strive to motivate and inspire my future students with opportunities to create like this.

My "get-to-know-you" Bingo contribution.

Survival camp prototypes! Good job everyone :)

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Problem-Based Learning

Problem-Based Learning Cycle
Today's session was on the process of problem-based learning, regarding cyber-bullying in schools. I was familiar with the problem-based learning approach, as we were introduced to it in my curriculum and instruction class. As Allexa mentioned, here is a video we created to engage and present the problem to our students. In today's workshop, we focused mostly on the analyzing the situation, and analyzing the problem steps of the PBL process.

In the afternoon, we were presented with information on a bullying case study, and generate questions that we had about the topic. Then, we got more information and checked to see if this information answered any of our questions. My group's questions were not answered by the information we were provided with did not answer questions, yet it examining the issue in-depth, as well as generating questions regarding the issues is something we will need to do as future teachers. After we spent some time doing this, we were given specific prompts to consider. Firstly, what are the warning signs of cyber-bullying, as evident in our case study, and then according to online research? Secondly, once the problem has been identified what policies and procedures can the school put in place to prevent cyber-bullying? And lastly, what should happen to the students responsible for the incidents of cyber-bullying?

We got into a very interesting discussion about the prevalence of bullying, the roles of "victim" and "bully," and the responsibility of teachers in addressing and preventing bullying. I think it is important to define "bullying," according to specific characteristics. Bullying is defined as repeated incidences of harm (physical, mental or emotional), where there is a power imbalance. In spite of the consensus that bullying is a problem in all of the participating countries, there seem to be different approaches, especially to the roles of victim and bully. I believe in a non-punitive approach to addressing bullying. I liked Jenne's "no-blame" method that is used in Belgium. It was very informative and interesting to compare the different approaches to dealing with bullies in the different countries. In Canada, as Allexa mentioned in her blog, there is a focus on changing social values - teaching bystanders that bullying is not cool, and bystanders should be standing up to bullies when they notice teasing is going on. Pink Shirt Day is a bullying awareness day, that takes place each year. Here is a really powerful video/poem on confronting bullying, by Shane Koyczan, a Canadian poet. The WITS program originated in Victoria, where I am from, and is designed to "create responsive environments to prevent peer victimization." This is one of many very common programs in many Canadian elementary schools. As we mentioned in class, there is no consistent way throughout the education system to address bullying - it is up to the school to design or implement a school-wide behaviour support plan/program to deal with these issues. My favourite program from Canada is the Roots of Empathy program, which has been proven to decrease aggression in all students, by teaching children empathy by bringing a baby into the classroom, and teaching the children to interact with the baby. I believe that teaching empathy is one of the most important social skills for children to learn in order to be decent and caring citizens. Empathy and compassion are the most important values that I have and I will strive to instill these in my students.

One thing that was reinforced today was that these issues are complex, and the more we examine an issue's components and try to come up with solutions, the more complex problems we encounter. While this may seem very discouraging, it is important to engage in the critical process so we at least have some ideas of how we will deal with these complicated problems in the future, even if we cannot come up with one overarching solution to the problem. All of the methods and techniques learned so far are useful in examining these issues ourselves, as well as teaching our students to become critical thinkers and creative problem solvers.

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

De Bono Theory

Today, on April 17th, we looked at using the De Bono approach to solving school problems and encouraging creativity and creative problem solving in our students. Prior to tackling the school programs, we participated in many warm-up activities to stimulate our own creativity, that we could use in our own classrooms. I enjoyed all of the activities we did throughout the workshop, and would like to integrate them in my own classroom practice. As Charlotte mentioned, we were able to learn by doing, which I think is more effective than simply providing us a list of activities to use. Additionally, the different activities throughout the day appealed to every learning style - group work, partner work, individual work, indoor activities, outdoor activities, sitting in a circle, sitting at our desks, auditory tasks, visual tasks and kinaesthetic tasks! This was super effective and allowed every learner to be reached at one point or another, while reinforcing the concepts in different ways.

Panda
We began by sitting in a circle around a bunch of animal toys, and choosing one according to our intuition. We then listed some characteristics of our chosen animal, and finally associated these characteristics with ourselves. We used the characteristics to describe ourselves to a partner. I chose a panda, mostly because I think they are cute. When it came to relating the panda to myself, I struggled a bit, as I didn't actually know much about pandas, other than that they eat bamboo, are very resourceful and eat and sleep a lot. I eat lots of vegetables, like to think that I am also resourceful, and I definitely eat and sleep a lot when time permits. It was a great activity for stimulating creative thinking and using metaphor for self-discovery. I would definitely use this activity in my classroom, for an introductory/ice-breaker, or to explore different issues, as Mo suggested in class. I found the use of toys effective for students who need concrete objects for understanding, especially for English-language-learners.

The Investigator
After this, we viewed different collages and rated how strongly we related to each collage, with either a 0, 5 or 10. I related most to "B," which turned out to be "The Investigator." As we found out, each collage related to a different way that people comfort themselves psychologically, related them to different animals, and then discussed what they might look like as students in our class, or lovers in relationships. The characteristics of The Investigator really resonated with me - I am always looking ahead, wondering "what if," needing to understand situations, needing an overview, and asking questions. I know that I was definitely like this as an elementary student, and it is easy to recognize in the students I work with in classrooms. I also found myself analyzing my friends and family and choosing the model I believed suited them the best. The point of this exercise was that when you are using the model that works best for you, you are totally engaged, energized, most creative and motivated. It is important for us to stimulate creativity in our students by providing them the opportunity to work with their best model. We also related these thinking models back to our students. This exercise would be a great assessment for learning tool to find out the ways that work best for your students. The two exercises progressed in a logical and effective sequence: first, we were engaged by the toy/animal activity, then the collage activity, before finally explaining the different psychological models.

Construction - We created a tableau out of the objects that we found that represented "construction," as well as our bodies.
We then went outside to find an original object in the environment that we thought best represented a certain word. We worked in partners, and then had to return with our object and justify why we chose that object. The active nature of this activity was engaging, and allowed us to get outside and interact with nature, which I found very stimulating. We discussed the exercise after and many of us felt that the competitive nature of the activity was negative, however I am sure that facilitators structured the exercise this way to prompt us to critically reflect on it. On one hand, the competition can be motivating for some students, however it could be intimidating for others, especially the end voting part. If I used it in my class, I would clarify in the end, just like we did, that creativity is subjective and there are no winners and losers.

De Bono Models of Thinking
Finally, after lunch, we discussed the De Bono approach to problem-solving one of our pre-task issues - children's lack of fitness. We went through and examined the ideas we brainstormed in the prior divergent thinking techniques (using post-its, random input, omission, reverse, wishful thinking, and exaggeration), converged them into categories (ordinary & realizable, ordinary & not realizable, original & realizable, original & not realizable). I would definitely use these brainstorming techniques in my future classrooms to elicit a variety of creative responses. Finally, we chose one of our suggestions, for example, having all school outside, and examined it through the lens of each thinking model. I think this is a really useful model to analyzing an issue and possible solutions to develop a well-rounded understanding and approach to problem-solving. We had an opportunity at the end to role-play being in an elevator and discussing the events of the day, to help prompt us to reflect but also to give the facilitators feedback on the class.

Overall, I really enjoyed today's session. I found the structure of the day to be very effective, and as I mentioned before, the variety of activities reached all of the students. While every student may not have enjoyed every single activity, there was at least one that appealed to each student. I will strive to design my own lessons in this manner, so that I can reach all of my students :)

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Drama Workshop

On April 16th, our workshop was on using drama as a method for addressing classroom issues, especially bullying, as this was a common concern in most to all of the countries participating in the IP. The workshop was structured around a lot of student choice - we were able to choose our warm-up activities (an energetic "boxercise" or a relaxing guided meditation), as well as our culminating activities (creating an art, music, or movie media project on bullying prevention in schools). We also did several role-playing activities, which naturally led to a discussion on how it felt to be in each role, as well as the cultural differences within each country's experiences with and approaches to bullying.
I was feeling quite tired and relaxed this morning, so I chose the guided meditation. I found it very grounding to begin the day with this kind of exercise - it helped me focus and think more clearly. I believe that an adapted guided meditation (depending on the age group) could be a good way to center students before engaging in a learning task. On the other hand, some students may need to expend some energy, so as we were able to choose today, it would be effective to offer students the choice between the two activities. This student-centred approach is very common in the Canadian school system, and we as teachers are encouraged to offer as much student choice and differentiated instruction, based on student interest and needs, as we can. This presents many challenges, such as finding valuable and worthwhile, engaging learning activities, that appeal to all students. Additionally, there can be many time-constraints in planning and classroom instruction time. Fortunately, professional learning networks make it easy to share ideas and resources among teachers, so we don't have "reinvent the wheel" as they say.


In our role-playing activities, we found it very difficult to even pretend to bully our peers, as we all understand that causing harm to others is morally wrong. An important point came up, however, that we cannot expect the same level of moral development from our students, as at certain ages, they may not have the developmental capacity to understand the nature or consequences of their actions. This is important to consider when we are deciding whether or not to use drama as a medium for addressing these issues. We must choose age appropriate activities and topics to include in our teaching practice. This is why it is important to have a solid understand of children's cognitive development when designing learning activities for various ages. Once again, thankfully there are many resources out there to choose from, especially in our teaching methods classes, and the internet.


Finally, the final product that I chose to create with the group was the poem/song. I chose this because of my background and experience in music. This talent-oriented approach drew on the unique talents and contributions of each student, allowing us all to express our understandings in the way most effective and comfortable to us. The biggest challenge in this particular case was the language barrier, as we Canadians are the only ones who speak English as our native language. I am very impressed by the language abilities of the other students in the IP, as I have no second language that I am nearly as fluent in, and I do not think I would be able to participate in a program like this in any other language! Nonetheless, we had fun creating a song on bullying prevention, focusing on positivity and embracing diversity. I would definitely use the talent-oriented approach in my future classroom, as this is a common approach in the Canadian school system.

Creativity & Creative Problem Solving

On April 15th, we had a workshop on creative problem solving. We discussed Guildford's factors of creativity - there are over one hundred of them, however we focused on only a dozen or so. At the end of the workshop, we were presented with some key questions to reflect on, in relation to the workshop. Firstly, what is our understanding of the models of creativity, and which factors affect us the most? Secondly, how is our new knowledge of creativity relevant to us as a future teacher? And finally, what cultural differences did we experience today in relation to creativity?
I learned about the models of creativity in terms of historical creativity and psychological creativity. Historical creativity is very unique, as it entails creativity that is a novel idea to society. We focused mostly on psychological creativity, which is the most relevant to us as teachers, as we will be trying to teach psychological, not historical, creativity to our students. We also discussed which factors were most important to us as a group, as well as individually. My group chose sensitivity as the most important, because we need to be sensitive to the needs, abilities and personalities of our students, in order to draw upon their inner creativity. I personally feel that flexibility is the most important factor of creativity, because we need to be adaptable, responsive and flexible to these needs of our students. I believe that the factors of creativity are important to teachers because we can integrate activities that address these factors within our classrooms. For example, we can use divergent thinking activities, such as mind maps from a single term or word, and convergent thinking activities, such as draw one picture from a variety of criteria, to encourage creativity.
Regarding cultural differences, I noticed that Denmark and Canada's approaches to creativity were very similar. Both Denmark and Canada believe that there is a variety of learning styles that we as teachers should address and encourage within our students. While both countries believe that students should get stimuli from all different teaching methods, Canada focuses more on student-freedom and student-choice with which methods they would like to use. I hadn't realized before that Canada had a more progressive approach to creativity and creative thinking compared to other educational systems throughout the world. These considerations are very important to teachers, especially if we want to teach internationally. We must be aware of the educational system we are working within, while also striving to foster creativity and creative thinking in our own unique ways.